Guernsey Crest Ice Cream Co Menu (Update 2025)
Introducing the menu at Guernsey Crest Ice Cream Co, located in Paterson, NJ, offers a delightful array of ice cream treats and beverages. Customers rave about the generous portions, unique flavors, and friendly service. From milkshakes to root beer floats, they cater to various tastes. One standout item is the Lucuma 1/2 Gallon, a Peruvian specialty flavor that is pre-packed and affordable at $12. The ice pops, including the Paleton Fresh Fruit Pops and Character Face Pops, are also popular choices. The reviews highlight the nostalgic charm of the location, the homemade quality of the ice cream, and the attentive staff. With over almost 100 years of experience, Guernsey Crest Ice Cream Co has become a beloved destination for those seeking delicious, high-quality ice cream.
Junior Cup of Ice Cream
1 flavor and 2 toppings max.
Small Cup of Ice Cream
Up to 2 flavors, 3 toppings max.
Large Cup of Ice Cream
Up to 3 flavors, 3 toppings max.
Pint of Ice Cream
Fresh packed.
Quart
Fresh-packed.
Sundae
Comes with 1 or 2 flavors, 1 topping with whip cream and cherry. Can add up to 3 additional toppings for an extra cost.
Banana Boat
Comes with 2 or 3 flavors, 2 toppings, whip cream and cherry. Can add up to 6 additional toppings for an extra cost.
1/2 Gallon
Pre-packed.
2.5 Gallon Can
Party size for any occasion. Serves 30-50 people.
Tartufo
Classic ice cream dessert vanilla chocolate with cherry and almonds in the center covered by a chocolate shell.
Regular Cone
For 2.
Sugar Cone
For 1.
Waffle Cone
For 1.
Cup of Sprinkles
8 oz.
Cup of Topping
8 oz.
Character Face Pops
Power Puff Girls, Spider-Man, Sponge Bob.
Paleton Fruit Bar
Coconut (with milk), strawberry (with milk), lime, watermelon, mango, and pineapple.
Milkshake
20 oz. 1 or 2 flavors and up to 3 toppings.
Malted Milkshake
20 oz. 1 or 2 flavors - up to 3 toppings.
Root Beer Float
20 oz. 1 or 2 flavors.
Beverages
Ice Pops
Paleton Fresh Fruit Pops
Character Face Pop
Spiderman, SpongeBob, PowerPuff.
Peruvian Specialty Flavor
Pre-packed.